Anatomy-Physiotherapy-logo

  • Italiano (Italia)
  • Français (France)
  • Portuguese (PT)
  • Deutsch (Deutschland)
  • Spanish (ES)
  • English (UK)
New english website, click here ->

           

  • Articles
    Evidence based articles
    • Musculoskeletal
      • Upper extremity
      • Lower extremity
      • Spine
    • Other
      • Nervous
      • Circulatory
      • Nutrition
      • Aging
      • Pain
      • Various
  • Art & Design
    Anatomy related art
  • Videos
    Webinars & more
  • Create account
    Personal pages & favourites
  • Login
    Login to A&P
Anatomy-Physiotherapy-logo
18 Apr2016

18 April 2016.

Written by Henrike Greuel
Posted in Lumbar

18-04-2016 06:37:20
neuroradiologycases
Image by: neuroradiologycases

Lumbar spinal stenosis - surgery vs. conservative treatment

It has been shown that complex fusion procedures are increasingly applied to treat patients with lumbar spinal stenosis (LSS). However, no studies so far have proven that surgical treatments are indeed more effective than conservative treatments in LSS. This study systematically reviewed literature to compare the effects of surgical and non-surgical treatment in LSS. It could not be concluded that either surgical treatment or a conservative approach is better for lumbar spinal stenosis. However, the surgical approach showed higher side effects, whereas no side effects could be reported in conservative treatment.

Lumbar spinal stenosis (LSS) describes a clinical syndrome with diminished space for the neural and vascular elements in the lumbar spinal canal. Although the overall rate of surgeries in LSS decreased slightly, the rate of complex fusion procedures increased 15-fold. Given the high economic effects associated with surgical treatments, the question is whether surgical procedures show better outcomes than conservative treatments. This study evaluated the effects of different types of surgery compared with different types of non-surgical interventions in LSS on quality of life, disability, function and pain.They included RCTs and quasi-randomised controlled studies.

A total of 5 RCTs were included in this review, however all studies included in this review were of low quality. 3 studies compared a conservative treatment with a decompression surgery and showed similar results for diability at 3, 6 and 12 months. At 24 months, one study reported better results after the surgical decompression. One study compared steroid injections versus mild decompression and showed no differences in disability (ODI) at six weeks, but better results for physical function and worse results for pain after injections. One single study found better results after a surgical decompression compared to conservative treatment at six weeks, six months and one year of follow-up.

One study reported complications in 10% and 24% of participants, including spinous process fracture, coronary ischaemia, respiratory distress, haematoma, stroke, risk of reoperation and death due to pulmonary oedema.

Thus, there is no clear evidence whether surgical or a conservative approach is better for LSS. However, the rate of side effects was higher in surgical cases. These findings suggest that clinicians should be very careful in informing patients about possible treatment options, especially given that conservative treatment options have resulted in no reported side effects.

> From: Zaina et al., Cochrane Database Syst Rev (2016) CD010264(Epub ahead of print). All rights reserved to The Cochrane Collaboration.Click here for the Pubmed summary.

minsurg
Image by: minsurg

Tags: Lumbar spinal stenosis, treatment, surgery, conservative treatment, spine, Lumbar spine

Please log in or create an account to place comments. It's free and takes only a minute.

About the Author
Henrike Greuel
Henrike Greuel
Henrike graduated in 2006 as a Physiotherapist in Germany. She has worked for a total of three years as a physiotherapist in Peru, Germany, and India ...

Latest articles from this auhtor

  • How to assess knee joint effusion in knee osteoarthritis
  • How to manage patellofemoral treatment?
  • Effects of visceral manipulation on low back pain
  • Therapy effects 12 years after a disc herniation operation
  • How do shrug-exercises affect the medial scapular muscles?
 

 

Login

  • Forgot your password?
  • Forgot your username?
  • Create an account
AP banner Sono 1

Related

  • Physical Therapy interventions for degenerative lumbar spinal stenosis: a systematic review.
  • Thoracic outlet syndrome: A neurological and vascular disorder.
  • Therapeutic ultrasound for acute ankle sprains.
  • Fractures of the scapula.
  • Facilitation of pain in the human spinal cord by nocebo treatment.

Sub Menu

  • Musculoskeletal
    • Upper extremity
      • Shoulder
      • Elbow
      • Wrist
      • Hand
    • Lower extremity
      • Hip
      • Knee
      • Ankle
      • Foot
    • Spine
      • Pelvis
      • Lumbar
      • Thoracic
      • Rib cage
      • Cervical
  • Other
    • Nervous
    • Circulatory
    • Nutrition
    • Aging
    • Pain
    • Various

Newsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter to receive all articles of the week in your mailbox.

 

Partners

enraf nonius

apa

fontys

vpt

kiné care

ICMSU

  • Home
  • About
  • Team
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Jobs
  • Newsletter archive
AP-SMALL-WHITECopyright 2010 - 2021 Anatomy & Physiotherapy. All Rights Reserved.

Privacy Policy

AdBlock detected

We want to keep offering top-notch content for free. In order to keep up with the additional costs that we incurr with scaling our website, we need your help! Please turn off your adblocker or consider donating a small amount.

http://www.anatomy-physiotherapy.com/donate

Close
You can also just close this popup. It shows only once.
isApp.it
  • Articles
    Evidence based articles
    • Musculoskeletal
      • Upper extremity
        • Shoulder
        • Elbow
        • Wrist
        • Hand
      • Lower extremity
        • Hip
        • Knee
        • Ankle
        • Foot
      • Spine
        • Pelvis
        • Lumbar
        • Thoracic
        • Rib cage
        • Cervical
    • Other
      • Nervous
      • Circulatory
      • Nutrition
      • Aging
      • Pain
      • Various
  • Art & Design
    Anatomy related art
  • Videos
    Webinars & more
  • Create account
    Personal pages & favourites
  • Login
    Login to A&P
You are now being logged in using your Facebook credentials